We have been very, very lucky here in San Diego to witness the birth of four healthy panda cubs. Each time, Bai Yun gave birth to a single infant and showed strong maternal instincts, so much so that staff need only sit by and watch her care for it. Bai Yun has always given the best of all possible circumstances. But in looking at the range of possibilities surrounding any cub birth, frankly, we have had it quite easy; pandas are certainly capable of more complex birthing scenarios than we have observed with Bai Yun.
As many of you know, pandas in managed cared routinely give birth to twins. In fact, they twin nearly 50 percent of the time–that’s a lot of panda cubs! However, in the wild, there are very few accounts of pandas rearing twins. A limited number of anecdotes of wild panda twins do exist, but in most cases they have not been verified. What is happening between the time of birth and weaning that is resulting in the loss of a twin?
There are many possible factors at play. For one, delayed implantation may be a culprit. Since panda cubs are thought to develop for only about 40-50 days once they implant, they have a very short window to go from a tiny group of undifferentiated cells to becoming a cub capable of making it “on the outside.” If the trigger that leads to implantation causes one potential twin to implant early, and the other a few days later, then at birth one cub could be more underdeveloped or weaker than its twin. As a result, it may not be strong enough to survive.
Another possibility is that it is just pretty near impossible for the panda mother to care for two. You who have watched Bai Yun with any of her cubs are aware of how intense a period the neonatal stage is for her. She is constantly cradling her infant, foregoing her own nourishment while she licks, comforts, and maintains her cub. She uses both paws to hold it, aid it in nursing bouts, and snuggle it close to her for warmth. Imagine how much harder it would be with two cubs. She would need more effort, and probably more paws! Two demanding infants needing her constant care might prove too difficult a task for even our super mom to handle.
Which is not to say she might not try. Several females in managed care have been observed giving it their best when they give birth to multiples. Some may even hold twins in their arms for a day or two before giving up. Frequently, these mothers are more prone to exhaustion, as keeping up with the demands of two cubs leaves them less time to rest quietly. Frankly, an exhausted mom is more likely to make mistakes… and historically, exhausted or stressed moms have been known to roll over onto a cub while they sleep.
In Wolong, there is always an effort to remove a twin from its mother’s care as soon as it is set down or rejected by its mother. The cub is then whisked away for intensive care in the nursery and, if healthy, will ultimately see its mother again when twin swapping commences. However, before such techniques were implemented, most twin litters resulted in one live cub and one that did not make it. Bai Yun is herself a product of a twin litter in which she is the only remaining “cub.”
We are pleased for our colleagues in Vienna that a cub has been born to them and that their female appears to be taking good care of her neonate. I know many of you have expressed concern over the loss of the twin cub she apparently had. Though I share a disappointment over the loss of the twin, I hope the information above will help you to place this loss in the proper context and understand this can happen anywhere you find pandas: in the wild or in captivity. It is part of the mystery of panda reproduction as a whole, something we continue to try to unravel with our research both here and in the wilds of Foping, China.
Suzanne Hall is a senior research technician with the Giant Panda Unit of Applied Animal Ecology/CRES.